Record Barrels Fund a Thirty-Percent Bigger Capital Budget, Not the Holder
Key Takeaways
- The operating machine beat again, and on the right basis the earnings did too. Total own production of 3,512 Mboed was a third consecutive quarterly record, up 5.3% sequentially and 11.7% year over year, and refining segment EBITDA rose 65.1% to $5,880M. Recurring earnings of $1.45 per ADS beat the $1.23 consensus by 17.5%. Revenue of $32,962M beat the most-cited $31.3B estimate by 5.3% and a $31.6B set by 4.3%, though it fell 0.4% short of a higher $33.1B set. The $1.20 IFRS figure that drew "miss" headlines carries a net $2,387M of pre-tax one-off charges.
- The capital budget took the windfall before the holder could. Management raised 2026 cash capex guidance to $21-22B from $16.9B, total capex to $24-25.5B from $19.4B, manageable operating expenses to $24.2-25.5B from $20.2B and lease payments to $11-11.5B from $10B. On the CFO's own account the budget rose because Brent did, and asked whether 2027 gives any of it back, engineering answered: "Next year, we plan to keep up the same pace."
- Nine percent of revenue is now a federal subsidy, and the per-litre rate nearly doubled at quarter end. The three subsidy lines contributed $3,044M, up 45.0% sequentially, the receivable rose 56.8% to $3,168M, and from September 27 the diesel subsidy runs at R$2.12 a litre against R$1.12 before. Strip the subsidy and revenue was $29,918M, 4.4% below the most-cited total-revenue estimate. The crude export tax that was to lapse within 60 days now runs to December 31.
- The distribution shrank while the political floor moved. The R$15.3B declaration, $0.43 per ADS, is 12% below August in reais and 18% below in dollars, and it is paid in February and March 2027. It follows a runoff that cost the ADR 14.0% in one session and precedes a five-year plan due November 23, with a $1.4B Braskem recapitalisation proposed jointly by Petrobras and its co-controller still on the table.
- Rating: Downgrading to Underperform from Hold. None of the three upgrade signposts we published in August was met, one downgrade signpost fired outright when the export tax was extended, and a second is being negotiated in the Braskem talks. Our fair value falls to $14-17 per ADS, below the $17.82 close.
Results vs. Consensus
3Q26 Scorecard
| Metric | 3Q26 Actual | Consensus | Beat/Miss | Magnitude |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales revenues vs. most-cited estimate (US$M) | 32,962 | 31,300 | Beat | +5.3% |
| Sales revenues vs. second estimate set (US$M) | 32,962 | 31,590 | Beat | +4.3% |
| Sales revenues vs. higher estimate set (US$M) | 32,962 | 33,091 | Slight miss | -0.4% |
| Sales revenues excl. subsidy programs (US$M) | 29,918 | n/a | n/a | -5.0% QoQ |
| Recurring EPS (US$ per ADS) | 1.45 | 1.23 | Beat | +17.5% |
| IFRS EPS (US$ per ADS) | 1.20 | n/a | n/a | +28.4% YoY |
| Adjusted EBITDA excl. one-off events (US$M) | 18,394 | n/a | n/a | -7.8% QoQ |
| Operating cash flow (US$M) | 12,026 | n/a | n/a | -1.8% QoQ |
| Free cash flow (US$M) | 6,618 | n/a | n/a | -13.6% QoQ |
| Shareholder remuneration declared (US$M) | 2,786 | n/a | n/a | -18.2% QoQ |
| Total own production (Mboed) | 3,512 | n/a | Record | +11.7% YoY |
| Refining utilization factor | 99% | n/a | n/a | -2pp QoQ |
| Gross debt (US$M) | 69,970 | n/a | n/a | -1.2% QoQ |
The basis question, a third time. More than one estimate set circulated, as in each of the prior two quarters. The most-cited estimate of $1.23 per ADS was framed as roughly 50% growth on the year-ago quarter, which ties to the $0.81 of 3Q25 net income excluding one-off events (US$5,235M over 12,888,732,761 weighted-average shares at two shares per ADS) and not to the $0.94 IFRS figure, which would have implied 31%. Consensus is therefore on the recurring basis, and the matching actual is $1.45, a 17.5% beat. Wire headlines compared the $1.20 IFRS actual against a $1.24 estimate from the same set and called it a 3% miss. A higher set at $1.38 also circulated; against it the recurring figure beats by 4.8%. The beat is real on every like-for-like basis. Its composition is the problem, as the quality section below sets out.
Income Statement, 3Q26 vs. 3Q25
| US$ millions | 3Q26 | 3Q25 | YoY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales revenues | 32,962 | 23,477 | +40.4% |
| Cost of sales | (15,271) | (12,260) | +24.6% |
| Gross profit | 17,691 | 11,217 | +57.7% |
| Gross margin | 53.7% | 47.8% | +589 bps |
| Selling expenses | (1,797) | (1,360) | +32.1% |
| General and administrative | (513) | (501) | +2.4% |
| Exploration costs | (208) | (248) | -16.1% |
| Research and development | (306) | (233) | +31.3% |
| Other taxes | (752) | (149) | +404.7% |
| Impairment (losses) reversals, net | 0 | 287 | n/m |
| Other income and expenses, net | (2,604) | (1,037) | +151.1% |
| Total operating expenses | (6,180) | (3,241) | +90.7% |
| Operating income | 11,511 | 7,976 | +44.3% |
| Operating margin | 34.9% | 34.0% | +95 bps |
| Net finance income (expense) | (592) | 271 | n/m |
| Results of equity-accounted investments | 68 | 36 | +88.9% |
| Net income before income taxes | 10,987 | 8,283 | +32.6% |
| Income taxes | (3,240) | (2,230) | +45.3% |
| Effective tax rate | 29.5% | 26.9% | +257 bps |
| Net income for the period | 7,747 | 6,053 | +28.0% |
| Attributable to shareholders of Petrobras | 7,740 | 6,027 | +28.4% |
| Net margin | 23.5% | 25.7% | -219 bps |
| Basic and diluted EPS (US$ per ADS) | 1.20 | 0.94 | +28.4% |
| Recurring net income attributable (US$M) | 9,316 | 5,235 | +78.0% |
| Recurring EPS (US$ per ADS) | 1.45 | 0.81 | +78.0% |
Income Statement, 3Q26 vs. 2Q26
| US$ millions | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | QoQ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales revenues | 32,962 | 33,607 | -1.9% |
| Cost of sales | (15,271) | (14,114) | +8.2% |
| Gross profit | 17,691 | 19,493 | -9.2% |
| Gross margin | 53.7% | 58.0% | -433 bps |
| Other taxes | (752) | (1,184) | -36.5% |
| Other income and expenses, net | (2,604) | (1,131) | +130.2% |
| Total operating expenses | (6,180) | (5,240) | +17.9% |
| Operating income | 11,511 | 14,253 | -19.2% |
| Operating margin | 34.9% | 42.4% | -749 bps |
| Net finance income (expense) | (592) | (288) | +105.6% |
| Net income before income taxes | 10,987 | 14,068 | -21.9% |
| Income taxes | (3,240) | (3,630) | -10.7% |
| Effective tax rate | 29.5% | 25.8% | +369 bps |
| Attributable to shareholders of Petrobras | 7,740 | 10,428 | -25.8% |
| Basic and diluted EPS (US$ per ADS) | 1.20 | 1.62 | -25.8% |
| Recurring net income attributable (US$M) | 9,316 | 11,073 | -15.9% |
| Recurring EPS (US$ per ADS) | 1.45 | 1.72 | -15.9% |
| Adjusted EBITDA | 16,703 | 18,615 | -10.3% |
| Adjusted EBITDA excl. one-off events | 18,394 | 19,959 | -7.8% |
| Adjusted EBITDA margin | 51% | 55% | -4.0pp |
| Operating cash flow | 12,026 | 12,250 | -1.8% |
| Free cash flow | 6,618 | 7,659 | -13.6% |
One-Off Events
| US$ millions | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | 3Q25 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net income | 7,747 | 10,438 | 6,053 |
| Impairment (losses) reversals | 0 | (160) | 289 |
| Results on disposal/write-offs of assets | (710) | 40 | 10 |
| Foreign exchange gains, real vs. dollar | 29 | 373 | 1,064 |
| Losses with legal, administrative and arbitration proceedings | (818) | (347) | (280) |
| Export tax on crude oil and diesel | (867) | (965) | 0 |
| One-off events, total (pre-tax) | (2,387) | (1,015) | 1,199 |
| Net effect of one-off events on income taxes | 811 | 370 | (407) |
| Net income excluding one-off events | 9,323 | 11,083 | 5,261 |
| Attributable to shareholders of Petrobras | 9,316 | 11,073 | 5,235 |
The table shows the main lines only; smaller items (co-participation results, debt repurchase discounts, decommissioning, the collective bargaining agreement and others) make up the balance of each column's pre-tax total. Net income excluding one-off events equals net income, less the pre-tax total, less the tax effect.
Quality of the beat: the recurring line keeps what Brasília pays and drops what Brasília takes. Petrobras' recurring earnings, the figure consensus is measured against, include $3,044M of federal subsidy revenue and exclude the $867M export tax as a one-off, even though the tax is now legally in force through December 31. Treat the export tax as the ordinary cost it has become, after tax at the 34% statutory rate, and recurring EPS is $1.36 per ADS, still 10.3% above consensus. Strip the subsidy as well, on the same basis, and it is $1.05, 15.0% below. At the statutory rate the subsidy alone is worth about $2.0B after tax, or 21.6% of the quarter's recurring net income. Two smaller items cut the other way and are genuinely cleaner than in August: the refining inventory effect was a $0.7B headwind rather than a $1.7B tailwind, and foreign exchange gains fell to $29M from $373M. The beat therefore rests less on accounting than it did in the second quarter and more on the treasury.
Revenue
Revenue fell 1.9% sequentially against a 7.2% decline in Brent, and the two halves of the business moved in opposite directions. Foreign-market revenue fell 12.8% to $11,260M. Crude export revenue fell 19.3% to $8,376M on volume that was essentially flat at 987 Mbpd against 996 Mbpd, an implied realisation of about $92.24 a barrel against a $97.00 Brent. In August the same calculation gave roughly $114.50 against $104.52. The company says 140 Mbpd of exports were still in transit at quarter end and will be recognised in the fourth quarter. Fuel oil exports, by contrast, rose 5.5% to $1,982M on record product export volumes.
Domestic revenue rose 4.9% to $21,702M on a 6.4% increase in oil products sales to 1,854 Mbpd, the highest volume since the third quarter of 2021, led by a 14.4% seasonal rise in diesel. But $945M of the $1,009M domestic increase is the growth in the subsidy lines, from $2,099M to $3,044M. Excluding them, domestic revenue rose 0.3% on 6.4% more volume. Group revenue excluding subsidies was $29,918M, 5.0% below the second quarter and 4.4% below the most-cited total-revenue estimate. The headline beat is a subsidy beat.
Margins
Gross margin of 53.7% fell 433 basis points from the second quarter's 58.0% and rose 589 basis points year over year. The sequential decline is mostly realisation: production taxes fell 10.6% to $4,119M with Brent, but acquisitions including imports rose 60.9% to $5,828M as oil products purchases more than tripled to $2,842M. Diesel imports rose to 110 Mbpd from 18 Mbpd as the harvest season lifted demand, which management had flagged in August.
Below gross profit the picture is noisier. Operating expenses rose 17.9% to $6,180M, and almost all of the increase sits in other income and expenses, which more than doubled to $2,604M. Two items explain most of it: a $696M charge for payment obligations under the 2019 TAG pipeline sale, triggered by an October regulatory tariff decision, and $818M of legal, administrative and arbitration losses. Other taxes fell 36.5% to $752M, mainly on a credit in the corporate segment; the export levy itself fell only 10.2% to $867M. Operating margin fell 749 basis points sequentially to 34.9%, and was 95 basis points above a year ago.
EPS
IFRS earnings of $1.20 per ADS fell 25.8% sequentially and rose 28.4% year over year; recurring earnings of $1.45 fell 15.9% and rose 78.0%. The gap between the two widened to $0.25 from $0.10 in August, and charges make up almost all of it: the TAG obligation, the legal provisions and the export tax, partly offset by an $811M tax effect and by only $35M of gains, $29M from foreign exchange and $6M from other items. Net finance expense doubled to $592M because the real-dollar exchange gain fell to $29M and $334M of hedge accounting was reclassified to the income statement. The effective tax rate of 29.5% is 369 basis points above the second quarter, which carried an unusually large interest-on-capital deduction; the third-quarter benefit was $745M against roughly $1,162M in the second.
Segment Performance
| US$ millions | Sales revenues | Gross profit | Operating income | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3Q26 | 2Q26 | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | |
| Exploration & Production | 19,049 | 22,785 | 10,119 | 13,435 | 9,157 | 12,456 |
| Refining, Transportation & Marketing | 31,608 | 32,351 | 7,620 | 5,185 | 5,148 | 2,809 |
| Gas & Low Carbon Energies | 2,554 | 2,406 | 1,175 | 1,086 | (347) | 274 |
| Corporate and other businesses | 113 | 99 | 10 | 12 | (1,214) | (1,061) |
| Eliminations | (20,362) | (24,034) | (1,233) | (225) | (1,233) | (225) |
| Total | 32,962 | 33,607 | 17,691 | 19,493 | 11,511 | 14,253 |
| Segment metrics | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | 3Q25 | QoQ | YoY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E&P operating income (US$M) | 9,157 | 12,456 | 7,802 | -26.5% | +17.4% |
| E&P adjusted EBITDA (US$M) | 12,686 | 15,874 | 10,922 | -20.1% | +16.2% |
| E&P EBITDA margin | 67% | 70% | 69% | -3.1pp | -2.8pp |
| E&P ROCE | 12.1% | 11.7% | 8.7% | +0.4pp | +3.4pp |
| RT&M operating income (US$M) | 5,148 | 2,809 | 856 | +83.3% | +501.4% |
| RT&M adjusted EBITDA (US$M) | 5,880 | 3,562 | 1,269 | +65.1% | +363.4% |
| RT&M EBITDA margin | 19% | 11% | 6% | +8pp | +13pp |
| RT&M ROCE | 15.5% | 9.2% | 1.0% | +6.3pp | +14.5pp |
| G&LCE operating income (US$M) | (347) | 274 | 51 | n/m | n/m |
| G&LCE adjusted EBITDA (US$M) | 521 | 419 | 203 | +24.3% | +156.7% |
| G&LCE EBITDA margin | 20% | 17% | 9% | +3pp | +11pp |
| Group ROCE | 10.5% | 9.3% | 5.7% | +1.2pp | +4.8pp |
Exploration & Production
The upstream produced more and earned less, which is the expected shape of a quarter in which Brent fell 7.2% and the realisation lag turned against the company. Segment revenue fell 16.4% and operating income 26.5% to $9,157M, while adjusted EBITDA fell 20.1% to $12,686M at a 67% margin. Year over year, operating income was still up 17.4% and segment ROCE rose to 12.1%. The transfer price to refining fell with Brent, which moved margin from the upstream to the downstream inside the group.
Volumes were exceptional. Oil and NGL production in Brazil rose 5.3% to 2,832 Mbpd, with pre-salt up 6.7% to 2,454 Mbpd on the ramp-up of P-78 and P-79 and FPSO Alexandre de Gusmao reaching and then exceeding its design peak. The company recorded its highest quarterly operating efficiency since the fourth quarter of 2018 and a September monthly record of 2.91 MMbpd. Lifting cost fell 3.4% to $6.12 per boe, the lowest since the third quarter of 2024, and the full cost including production taxes and leases fell 12.0% to $23.36 as government take fell with the oil price.
One disclosure on the call trims the fourth quarter, and it is a direct transfer to the state.
"Petrobras reached the cost recovery ceiling for the field, and under the contractual arrangements, starting in the fourth quarter of 2026, we will start to share with the federal government approximately 85,000 barrels per day."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
Assessment: Bull pillar one is confirmed again, and the efficiency evidence is stronger than at any point in our coverage: eleven platforms operating above design capacity is a genuine engineering result. The Búzios profit-oil step-down is the contractual mechanics of a production-sharing field rather than a surprise, but it means roughly 85,000 barrels a day of the company's best barrels start going to the government from October, and it was disclosed only in passing.
Refining, Transportation & Marketing
Refining finally converted its operating record into earnings. Segment gross profit rose 47.0% to $7,620M, operating income rose 83.3% to $5,148M and adjusted EBITDA rose 65.1% to $5,880M at a 19% margin, against 11% in August. Excluding the inventory effect, which the company puts at a $0.7B headwind this quarter against a $1.7B tailwind in the second, gross profit was $8.3B against $3.5B. The drivers were higher domestic volume, record fuel oil exports and a wider margin on crude exported through the segment as the upstream transfer price fell.
Utilisation dipped to 99% from 101% during a planned RPBC shutdown and output fell 2.3% to 1,873 Mbpd, yet diesel production set a quarterly record at 769 Mbpd. Refining cost rose 9.4% to $3.48 a barrel on the collective bargaining agreement and maintenance spending.
"We've been able to increase diesel production to 769,000 barrels per day, record-breaking numbers without building new refineries."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
Two state flows sit inside this segment and should be read against the margin. All $3,044M of subsidy revenue is booked in refining's domestic sales, and the segment's other taxes of $888M carry most of the $867M crude export tax. The subsidy exceeds the tax by roughly $2.2B, which is about 37% of the segment's adjusted EBITDA.
Assessment: Bull pillar two is confirmed financially for the first time in our coverage, not merely operationally. The caveat is that roughly a third of the segment's earnings is the net of a federal payment and a federal levy, and both are temporary instruments. A refining business earning 19% EBITDA margins with the treasury's help is a weaker asset than one earning them alone.
Gas & Low Carbon Energies
The smallest segment had its best underlying quarter and its worst reported one. Gross profit rose 8.2% to $1,175M and adjusted EBITDA rose 24.3% to $521M at a 20% margin, driven by capacity reserve contracts that took effect in August and three thermal plant contracts brought forward to September; fixed auction revenue more than doubled to $153.52M. The natural gas price fell 2.9% to $9.68 per MMBtu and the average electricity price fell 37.2%. Operating income turned to a $347M loss on the $696M TAG obligation, an accrual for payments owed to the 2019 buyer once the regulator set the 2026 to 2030 tariff assumptions, which the company says remain subject to appeal.
Assessment: The contracted thermal capacity is doing what we expected, converting idle plants into fixed revenue. The TAG charge is a reminder that this company's divestments carry tails that land in later periods, and the company frames it as a one-off. On November 12, before this note, Petrobras also agreed to buy the remaining 70% of the Logum ethanol pipeline company for R$620M, one more small addition to a widening capital programme.
Revenue by Product, and the Subsidy Line
The subsidy lines are now larger than domestic crude and natural gas revenue combined, $3,044M against $2,054M, and larger than the entire jet fuel line.
| US$ millions | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | 3Q25 | QoQ | YoY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diesel | 8,015 | 7,584 | 7,117 | +5.7% | +12.6% |
| Road-use diesel subsidy program | 2,699 | 1,923 | n/a | +40.4% | n/m |
| Gasoline | 3,116 | 3,013 | 3,084 | +3.4% | +1.0% |
| Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) | 920 | 942 | 941 | -2.3% | -2.2% |
| Gasoline and LPG subsidy programs | 345 | 176 | n/a | +96.0% | n/m |
| Jet fuel | 1,775 | 1,893 | 1,112 | -6.2% | +59.6% |
| Naphtha | 572 | 784 | 440 | -27.0% | +30.0% |
| Fuel oil (including bunker fuel) | 186 | 213 | 136 | -12.7% | +36.8% |
| Other oil products | 1,257 | 1,213 | 938 | +3.6% | +34.0% |
| Subtotal oil products | 18,885 | 17,741 | 13,768 | +6.4% | +37.2% |
| Natural gas | 918 | 899 | 1,019 | +2.1% | -9.9% |
| Crude oil | 1,136 | 1,358 | 1,040 | -16.3% | +9.2% |
| Renewables, nitrogen, breakage, electricity, services | 763 | 695 | 539 | +9.8% | +41.6% |
| Total domestic market | 21,702 | 20,693 | 16,366 | +4.9% | +32.6% |
| Exports: crude oil | 8,376 | 10,381 | 5,408 | -19.3% | +54.9% |
| Exports: fuel oil (including bunker fuel) | 1,982 | 1,879 | 1,193 | +5.5% | +66.1% |
| Exports: other oil products and other products | 642 | 405 | 302 | +58.5% | +112.6% |
| Sales abroad | 260 | 249 | 208 | +4.4% | +25.0% |
| Total foreign market | 11,260 | 12,914 | 7,111 | -12.8% | +58.3% |
| Total sales revenues | 32,962 | 33,607 | 23,477 | -1.9% | +40.4% |
| Memo: total subsidy programs | 3,044 | 2,099 | n/a | +45.0% | n/m |
| Memo: revenue excluding subsidy programs | 29,918 | 31,508 | 23,477 | -5.0% | +27.4% |
The interim financial statements list every programme that produced revenue this year, and the list shows the mechanism changing shape rather than winding down.
| Fuel | Provisional Measure | Period | Rate | Net revenue, 9M26 (US$M) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Road diesel "A" and "C" | 1,340/2026 | March 12 to 31 | R$0.32 per litre | 128 |
| Road diesel "A" and "C" | 1,340/2026 | April 1 to 6 | Up to R$0.32 per litre | 31 |
| Road diesel "A" and "C" | 1,340/2026 | April 7 to June 1 | Up to R$1.12 per litre | 995 |
| Road diesel "A" and "C" | 1,363/2026 | June 2 to September 26 | R$1.12 per litre | 3,005 |
| Road diesel "A" | 1,358/2026 | June 1 to 30 | R$351.51 per m³ | 220 |
| Road diesel "A" | 1,391/2026 | September 17 to 26 | R$1.00 per litre | 236 |
| Road diesel "A" | 1,391/2026 | September 27 onwards | R$2.12 per litre | 135 |
| Imported LPG | 1,349/2026 | April 1 to August 4 | Up to R$850 per ton | 11 |
| Gasoline | 1,358/2026 | May 29 to September 9 | R$0.44 per litre | 510 |
| Total, net of PIS and Cofins | 5,271 |
Three readings follow. The gasoline and LPG programmes ended in August and September, so the gasoline line's support has lapsed while gasoline remains, by management's own description, the product furthest from its pricing policy. The diesel programme did the opposite: a new measure added R$1.00 a litre alongside the R$1.12 programme from September 17, and from September 27, when the earlier programme's period ended, it pays R$2.12 on its own, with no end date in the disclosure. And the four days of the new rate that fall inside the quarter already produced $135M, so the fourth-quarter subsidy line will be larger than this one if diesel volumes hold.
Operating Metrics
| Metric | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | 3Q25 | QoQ | YoY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total own production (Mboed) | 3,512 | 3,336 | 3,144 | +5.3% | +11.7% |
| Crude oil, NGL and gas, Brazil (Mboed) | 3,483 | 3,308 | 3,114 | +5.3% | +11.8% |
| Crude oil and NGLs, Brazil (Mbpd) | 2,832 | 2,689 | 2,520 | +5.3% | +12.4% |
| Pre-salt | 2,454 | 2,299 | 2,117 | +6.7% | +15.9% |
| Post-salt, deep and ultra-deep | 341 | 356 | 366 | -4.2% | -6.8% |
| Onshore and shallow water | 36 | 34 | 36 | +5.9% | 0.0% |
| Natural gas, Brazil (Mboed) | 651 | 619 | 594 | +5.2% | +9.6% |
| Total operated production (Mboed) | 5,082 | 4,866 | 4,540 | +4.4% | +11.9% |
| Refining utilization factor | 99% | 101% | 94% | -2.0pp | +5.0pp |
| Oil products output (Mbpd) | 1,873 | 1,918 | 1,790 | -2.3% | +4.6% |
| of which diesel | 769 | 764 | 721 | +0.7% | +6.7% |
| Domestic oil products sales (Mbpd) | 1,854 | 1,742 | 1,804 | +6.4% | +2.8% |
| of which diesel | 849 | 742 | 809 | +14.4% | +4.9% |
| Exports of crude and oil products (Mbpd) | 1,251 | 1,231 | 1,037 | +1.7% | +20.7% |
| of which crude oil | 987 | 996 | 814 | -0.9% | +21.3% |
| Imports of crude and oil products (Mbpd) | 333 | 156 | 314 | +114.1% | +6.1% |
| of which diesel | 110 | 18 | 121 | +518.0% | -8.8% |
| Net exports (Mbpd) | 918 | 1,075 | 723 | -14.6% | +27.0% |
| Lifting cost, Brazil (US$/boe) | 6.12 | 6.33 | 6.30 | -3.4% | -2.8% |
| Lifting cost + production taxes + leases (US$/boe) | 23.36 | 26.56 | 20.27 | -12.0% | +15.3% |
| Refining cost, Brazil (US$/bbl) | 3.48 | 3.18 | 2.97 | +9.4% | +17.2% |
| Brent crude (US$/bbl) | 97.00 | 104.52 | 69.07 | -7.2% | +40.4% |
| Implied crude export realisation (US$/bbl) | 92.24 | 114.54 | 72.21 | -19.5% | +27.7% |
| Price of basic oil products, domestic market (US$/bbl) | 113.06 | 114.60 | 84.54 | -1.3% | +33.7% |
| Average BRL/USD selling rate | 5.14 | 5.05 | 5.45 | +1.8% | -5.7% |
The export destination mix partly reverted. China took 40% of crude exports against 35% in the second quarter and 53% a year ago, the United States rose to 12% from 2%, and India fell to 8% from 22%. In August we flagged the halving of the China share as the test of whether diversification would survive a normalising Brent; one quarter in, it has held at roughly the second-quarter level rather than snapping back to the first quarter's 62%.
Cash Flow, Returns and Balance Sheet
| US$ millions unless stated | 3Q26 | 2Q26 | 3Q25 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net cash provided by operating activities | 12,026 | 12,250 | 9,856 |
| Acquisition of PP&E and intangible assets (cash capex) | (5,402) | (4,559) | (4,887) |
| Acquisition of equity interests | (6) | (32) | (2) |
| Free cash flow (Shareholder Remuneration Policy definition) | 6,618 | 7,659 | 4,967 |
| Repayment of lease liability | (2,670) | (2,775) | (2,415) |
| Free cash flow after lease repayments | 3,948 | 4,884 | 2,552 |
| Trade and other receivables (cash flow line) | (1,705) | (1,951) | (596) |
| Inventories (cash flow line) | (1,196) | (423) | (307) |
| Income taxes paid | (1,816) | (3,175) | (882) |
| Repayment of principal, finance debt | (1,487) | (2,452) | (349) |
| Proceeds from finance debt | 1,163 | 614 | 2,243 |
| Dividends paid to shareholders (cash) | (1,569) | (1,511) | (2,030) |
| Total capex (company definition) | 6,424 | 5,299 | 5,510 |
| Return on capital employed (group, LTM) | 10.5% | 9.3% | 5.7% |
| Balance sheet items (US$ millions unless stated) | 09.30.2026 | 06.30.2026 | 09.30.2025 | QoQ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financial debt | 25,638 | 25,834 | 28,122 | -0.8% |
| Capital markets | 14,975 | 16,264 | 17,395 | -7.9% |
| Banking market | 8,548 | 7,293 | 8,836 | +17.2% |
| Development banks, export credit agencies and other | 2,115 | 2,277 | 1,891 | -7.1% |
| Finance leases | 44,332 | 44,972 | 42,589 | -1.4% |
| Gross debt | 69,970 | 70,806 | 70,711 | -1.2% |
| Adjusted cash and cash equivalents | 12,123 | 10,418 | 11,658 | +16.4% |
| Net debt | 57,847 | 60,388 | 59,053 | -4.2% |
| Net debt / LTM adjusted EBITDA | 1.00x | 1.14x | 1.53x | -12.3% |
| Gross debt / LTM adjusted EBITDA | 1.21x | 1.34x | 1.83x | -9.7% |
| Average interest rate (% p.a.) | 6.7 | 6.8 | 6.7 | -0.1pp |
| Weighted average maturity (years) | 11.84 | 11.92 | 11.36 | -0.7% |
| Fuel subsidy program receivable | 3,168 | 2,021 | n/a | +56.8% |
| Export tax payable | 580 | 579 | n/a | +0.2% |
| Dividends payable | 3,076 | n/a | 1,523 | n/a |
The distribution, smaller. The board declared R$15.3B, or R$1.18732774 per common and preferred share, which the company describes as 45% of free cash flow under the policy formula. The filing translates it at $2,786M, or $0.2161 per share and $0.43 per ADS, against $3,406M and $0.53 per ADS for the second quarter: 18.2% lower in dollars and 11.9% lower in reais. At least one Brazilian desk called it below expectations without publishing a figure. The dollar figure is 42% of the dollar free cash flow because the filing's translation implies roughly R$5.49 to the dollar against a 5.14 quarterly average. Post-lease free cash flow of $3,948M covers it 1.42 times. It is paid in two instalments on February 22 and March 22, 2027 for B3 holders and from March 1 and March 29 for ADR holders, Selic-indexed from December 31, the same three-to-four-month lag as the second-quarter declaration. Whether it is paid as dividends or interest on capital will be set by December 10, which matters to offshore holders: dividends abroad carry a 10% withholding from January 1, 2026, and interest on capital 17.5%.
The receivable, larger. The fuel subsidy receivable rose to $3,168M at September 30 from $2,021M at June 30, even though the company announced cumulative receipts of roughly R$13.3B by September 30 and roughly R$16B by October 13. The interim statements disclose a further $538M received in October and say the remainder "is awaiting documentation analysis by ANP." Trade and other receivables consumed $1,705M of operating cash, and inventories another $1,196M on crude in transit at quarter end.
Key Topics & Management Commentary
Overall Management Tone: Management was expansive on operations and defensive on capital: most of the prepared remarks argued that a larger budget is buying earlier barrels, and the cost revisions were framed per barrel rather than in dollars. Unlike August, the subsidy and the war were named, and governance continuity was addressed directly from the chair. On pricing, which took five of the twelve questions, the answers were non-committal and deferred to an internal review, the least convincing passage of the three calls we have covered.
1. The Capital Budget Resets to the Oil Price
The single most consequential disclosure of the quarter came in a Material Fact the evening before the call. Cash investment guidance for the portfolio under implementation rose to $21-22B from $16.9B, a 24% to 30% increase, and total capex to $24-25.5B from $19.4B. E&P capex rose to $20-21.3B from $14.8B; refining capex was held at $3.0-3.2B. Nine-month cash capex was $14.5B, so the fourth quarter is guided at $6.5-7.5B, including roughly $0.6B of signature bonuses for the 21 blocks won at the October auctions.
Management's explanation was candid about the causality.
"The resulting increase in cash generation enabled us to step up investment execution because we went from an expected Brent of $63 to something of around $90-$100 on average per year."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
The decomposition offered on the call: more than $1B from exchange rates, about 40% of the increase from faster construction of owned FPSOs for Búzios, Atapu and Sépia, about $600M from the local-content nationalisation of Búzios 9 and 10, and about $500M of additional subsea tie-ins. The CFO stressed that "our project costs are fully in line with our plans," and management sized the payoff at 200,000 to 300,000 barrels a day of additional production this year.
Assessment: This is bear pillar two in its cleanest form, stated by the CFO: a higher oil price produced more cash, and more cash produced more capex. We accept that the projects are on budget and that acceleration in a high-price window has value; the production results prove the execution. The problem is the decision rule. In May we named "a 2026 capex figure revised above $21B" as a downgrade signpost. Total capex is now guided at $24-25.5B and cash capex at $21-22B, and the revision came two weeks before a new five-year plan is published.
2. Opex and Leases Follow the Budget Up
Manageable operating expenses were raised to $24.2-25.5B from $20.2B, a 20% to 26% increase, which goes well beyond August's warning that expenses "may exceed the projection." Lease payment guidance rose to $11-11.5B from $10B. Management attributed the opex increase to exchange rates, higher production including P-79's early start, and freight.
"Freight rates have been exceptionally high in 2026, as we can all see, as an effect of the geopolitical conflicts underway."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
The company's defence is per barrel: manageable operating expenses per barrel produced are projected 2% below the 2025 actual. Nine-month lease payments of $7,886M imply $3.1-3.6B in the fourth quarter against $2,670M in the third, and management said roughly 75% of the lease increase comes from offshore support vessels and about 15 oil transport vessels.
Assessment: The per-barrel argument is fair and the absolute increase is the one that reaches the cash flow statement. Opex, capex and leases were all reset upward at once, by a combined $9B to $12B against the original guidance, which moves the all-in cash breakeven up even as lifting cost per barrel falls.
3. Where the Extra Cash Goes
The same Material Fact raised 2026 operating cash flow guidance to $45-50B from $35B, which management described as "up to US$ 15 billion in additional cash generation." Taking the midpoints, operating cash flow rises about $12.5B, cash capex about $4.6B and lease payments about $1.25B. Capex and leases therefore absorb roughly 47% of the incremental operating cash before any distribution is calculated, and the 45% policy then returns about 28% of the incremental operating cash to all shareholders, the federal government among them.
"Operating cash flow also ensured the payment of dividends to shareholders and helped reduce the company’s financial debt. As a result, we are accelerating profitable investments that make up the company’s unique portfolio, and we will continue to generate value through growth and operating cash flow."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer (results release)
Assessment: The ordering is the one management has stated since May: investment first, then debt, then shareholders. What changed is the size of the first claim. A windfall of this size used to raise the question of an extraordinary distribution; this quarter nobody asked, and the formula distribution fell.
4. Production Guidance Raised, and an 85,000 Barrel Haircut From the State
The oil production target was raised to 2.7-2.8 MMbpd from 2.5 MMbpd, total production to 3.3-3.4 MMboed from 3.1 and commercial production to 2.9-3.0 MMboed from 2.8. The nine-month average is 2.702 MMbpd of oil, so the low end of the range implies a fourth quarter of about 2.69 MMbpd, below the third quarter's 2.832, and the midpoint about 2.89. The CFO cited scheduled maintenance and the Búzios profit-oil step-down as the fourth-quarter headwinds. Eleven platforms now operate above design capacity, with authorisations worth up to 282 kbpd; P-80 is expected in the first quarter of 2027, P-82 in the second and P-83 in the second half.
"In the fourth quarter, we will still have some scheduled downtimes for maintenance, and we will also discount the WI in Búzios."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
Assessment: The guidance raise is conservative at the low end and the operating story is the best part of this thesis. But the step-down in Búzios is permanent rather than seasonal: production-sharing contracts hand more barrels to the state once cost recovery is reached, and it is happening in the company's largest field. Growth in reported production will outrun growth in barrels Petrobras keeps.
5. The Subsidy Doubles Per Litre and the Receivable Grows 57%
Subsidy revenue rose 45.0% to $3,044M, or 9.2% of total revenue, from $2,099M and 6.2% in the second quarter. The receivable rose 56.8% to $3,168M. And the diesel programme's rate nearly doubled, to R$2.12 a litre from September 27. After omitting it entirely in August, management addressed the subsidy in the prepared remarks this quarter, if only as a working-capital item.
"Operating cash flow was adversely affected by changes in working capital, mainly due to outstanding receivables under the fuel subsidy program and inventories related to exports in progress."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
In August the word "subsidy" did not appear in the transcript at all. This quarter the logistics director volunteered the connection between the federal payments and the pricing policy in the Q&A, a more honest framing than August's "public policy in force."
Assessment: We credit the improved disclosure. The economics moved the other way. A programme that recognised R$740M in the first quarter now carries a $3.2B receivable, a tenth of revenue, and is paid at a rate that rose 89% at the end of the quarter. The longer it runs, the more of the company's domestic margin is a function of the federal budget, and the harder it becomes to remove without a price increase that the pricing discussion in Topic 6 suggests management is reluctant to make.
6. The Price Policy Goes Under Review
Five of the twelve analyst questions concerned fuel pricing, and the answers shifted ground across the call. The logistics director first said no structural change was contemplated, then disclosed that internal discussions concern a "situational" change, then said diesel should meet the policy by year end while gasoline might not, and that the company "might extend the deadline" to meet the policy's limits. The CEO defended the posture by recalling what daily price-chasing had cost the company.
"As I said in my previous answer, we are currently in internal discussions to understand whether there is a need for any change, any non-structural, but rather situational change to that policy, considering our current scenario."
— Angélica Laureano, Executive Officer for Logistics, Commercialization and Market
"The result of this analysis was Petrobras lost money and lost market share. Market share is something that once we lose, we cannot get it back, because we allow the competition to build a logistic structure which becomes unequivocal in terms of their competition with us."
— Magda Chambriard, Chief Executive Officer
Assessment: The domestic price is now set by three parties at once: the company's policy, the treasury's subsidy and a board review whose outcome is undisclosed. A pricing policy whose measurement window can be extended when it is not met is a policy with an exit, and gasoline is explicitly the product that may need it. Bear pillar one escalates, and its timing now coincides with a re-elected government.
7. The Export Tax Did Not Lapse
In August the interim statements said the authorities had kept the crude and diesel export tax "in effect for up to 60 days, with reassessment scheduled after 30 days." The September statements say it has been maintained on crude oil until December 31, 2026 under three Camex resolutions, at 12%, or 6% for exports to the European Union; only the diesel leg was discontinued. The charge was $867M in the quarter and $1,954M for nine months, about $9.55 for every barrel of crude exported this quarter. It remains in the one-off schedule and it was not mentioned on the call.
Assessment: In August we listed "the export tax being extended or raised" as a downgrade signpost. It was extended. The tax costs roughly $0.9B a quarter on the export programme that carries the growth plan, and the company still classifies it as a one-off, which is why the recurring earnings line consensus is measured against does not bear it.
8. Refining Finally Earns, With the State on Both Sides of the Ledger
Refining's 19% EBITDA margin and 15.5% ROCE are the best in our coverage, and the drivers are partly genuine: domestic oil products sales of 1,854 Mbpd were the highest since the third quarter of 2021, diesel output set a record, and the crude export margin widened inside the segment. The CEO reported that utilisation was 91% in the second quarter of 2024 and 99% this quarter, with most refineries above 100% at points.
"In order for these 99% to happen, it means that we had scheduled downtimes, for instance. We are increasing, we are leveraging the utilization factors of refineries with profitability and security."
— Magda Chambriard, Chief Executive Officer
Assessment: Bull pillar two has finally passed the financial test we set in May. It passed with a federal subsidy of $3,044M booked in the segment's revenue and an export tax of $867M in its costs, so the segment's margin is set as much by policy as by cracks. Imports also returned, to 333 Mbpd from 156 Mbpd, with diesel at 110 Mbpd, a reminder that self-sufficiency is seasonal.
9. The Timing Lag Reverses, as Predicted
In August we wrote that the realisation lag swings about ten points a quarter and that the half is the right unit of analysis. The third quarter delivered the reversal: crude export realisation of about $92.24 against a $97.00 Brent, with 140 Mbpd of exports in transit at quarter end to be recognised in the fourth quarter. Over nine months the implied realisation is about $93.67 against a $94.05 Brent, essentially at parity.
"However, I must remind you that last September was the month with the highest Brent and that the prices of our exports are out of sync, which happened in March and which was reversed in the following quarter, and that will happen probably between the third and fourth quarters. You can see that these are temporary impacts."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
Assessment: The mechanics behaved as we described, and the fourth quarter opens with a timing tailwind from the 140 Mbpd in transit. On our price data Brent closed at $116.72 on October 23, but by November 10 it had fallen to $91.49, so the tailwind fades inside the quarter.
10. Net Debt Reaches the Plan Early; Gross Debt Does Not
Gross debt fell $836M to $69,970M, missing the $69B we set as an upgrade signpost by $970M. Net debt fell 4.2% to $57,847M because adjusted cash rose $1,705M to $12,123M, and net debt to LTM adjusted EBITDA fell to 1.00 times. The company repurchased and redeemed $1.2B of international bonds in the quarter, including an early redemption of notes due 2028, and raised $1.2B from banks. The CFO chose to frame the plan target in net terms.
"In the 2026-2030 business plan, we estimate a gross debt of $65 billion. If we deduct the $6 billion from our minimum cash balance, that would imply a net debt of $59 billion ... a condition that we were only expecting to reach in 2027."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
Separately, on November 4 Fitch raised Petrobras' standalone credit profile to bbb+ from bbb, its first standalone upgrade since 2020, while affirming the BB global-scale rating.
Assessment: The leverage story is better than the gross debt line, and the standalone upgrade is a fair external validation. But the reframing matters: in May the yardstick was $67B of gross debt in 2026, in August it disappeared, and in November it has been replaced by a net figure that a cash build can meet. Bear pillar three is softened, not resolved, and the distribution policy itself is conditioned on gross debt rather than net.
11. A Smaller Distribution From a Larger Budget
The R$15.3B declaration is the policy formula applied to a smaller free cash flow, and the free cash flow is smaller partly because cash capex rose 18.5% sequentially to $5,402M. Nine-month declarations total $8,037M, or about $1.25 per ADS. The amount did not appear in the prepared remarks or the Q&A; the only references were generic.
"We will keep on delivering the electricity that Brazil needs, generating dividends to those that believe in our company, in job positions, and in wealth for our society."
— Magda Chambriard, Chief Executive Officer
Assessment: Bull pillar four was graded on track in August because the policy was applied and covered. It is still applied and covered, 1.42 times. But a policy that pays 45% of what remains after capex returns less when capex rises, and management has just raised capex for 2026 and told us 2027 runs at the same pace. The distribution pillar moves to at risk because its base is now the variable management is choosing to grow.
12. Braskem: From a Minority Boundary to "We Will Be in Braskem"
In May the boundary on the petrochemical affiliate was explicit: no debt consolidation, and Petrobras stays a minority. In August it was not restated. Since then Braskem filed for extrajudicial recovery on August 24 to restructure roughly $10.9B of debt, and on the day of the call creditors were reported to have accepted a $1.4B capital contribution proposed jointly by Petrobras and its co-controller, while disputing how much debt converts to equity. The proposals are described as indicative and non-binding, and the company cited a deadline of the 22nd. The interim statements describe only the June shareholders' agreement, under which Petrobras holds 36.15% of the capital and 47.03% of the votes, and do not mention the restructuring.
"Yes, the board is within the strategic plan effort to increase Petrobras' synergies with Braskem when it comes to refinery."
— William França, Executive Officer for Industrial Processes and Products
Assessment: In August we wrote that "a Braskem capital commitment of any size" would be a downgrade signpost. A joint $1.4B proposal is on the table, and on the call the industrial director said "We will be in Braskem," that the company is "interested in closing an RE with Braskem," and that it has "until the 22nd" to do so. His answer addressed petrochemical integration; it did not address what guarantees Petrobras would need before putting money in, or how much it would put. The commitment is not yet signed. We treat the signpost as being pulled rather than fired, and we state now that a signed injection of any size confirms it.
13. A Re-Elected Government, a Plan Due November 23, and New Frontiers
The October 25 runoff returned the incumbent for a fourth term and the ADR fell 14.0% the next session; it had risen 11.5% after the first round, when the opposition led. Management did not mention the election. The CEO addressed its subtext directly instead, and the plan that will set the 2027 to 2031 envelope is due on November 23.
"Our commitment, you can be certain, is to create value for our shareholders. By shareholders, I am referring to both governmental and private shareholders."
— Magda Chambriard, Chief Executive Officer
The exploration portfolio widened again in the quarter: three oil discoveries in the Morpho well on the Equatorial Margin, 21 blocks at the October ANP rounds with R$3.2B of signature bonuses payable by December 30, eight production-sharing blocks in Ivory Coast at a 90% interest, Block 3 in São Tomé and Príncipe, and a gas discovery offshore Colombia. Separately, Petrobras will receive about $859M from its Berbigão and Sururu partners by November under unitisation equalisation agreements.
Assessment: The exploration results are good and the Equatorial Margin could matter for the 2030s. In a quarter when the company raised every headline cost line, though, a widening frontier portfolio reads as the next set of capital claims. The November 23 plan is where these claims become numbers, and the CEO's definition of shareholders tells us whose priorities it will weigh.
Guidance & Outlook
On November 10 nine of the ten 2026 lines below moved up; the tenth, refining capex, was held at $3.0-3.2B against $3.2B.
| 2026 projection | Prior | New | 9M26 actual | Implied 4Q26 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oil and NGL production (MMbpd) | 2.5 (+/-4%) | 2.7 to 2.8 | 2.702 | 2.69 to 3.09 | Raised |
| Commercial oil and gas production (MMboed) | 2.8 | 2.9 to 3.0 | 2.953 | n/a | Raised |
| Total oil and gas production (MMboed) | 3.1 | 3.3 to 3.4 | 3.359 | 3.12 to 3.52 | Raised |
| Total capex, implementation portfolio (US$B) | 19.4 (+/-5%) | 24.0 to 25.5 | 16.8 (all portfolios) | n/a | Raised |
| of which E&P (US$B) | 14.8 | 20.0 to 21.3 | 14.1 | n/a | Raised |
| of which refining, transportation and marketing (US$B) | 3.2 | 3.0 to 3.2 | 2.1 | n/a | Maintained |
| Cash investment, implementation portfolio (US$B) | 16.9 (+/-5%) | 21.0 to 22.0 | 14.5 | 6.5 to 7.5 | Raised |
| Operating cash flow, total portfolio (US$B) | 35 | 45 to 50 | 32.7 | 12.3 to 17.3 | Raised |
| Lease payments (US$B) | 10 | 11.0 to 11.5 | 7.9 | 3.1 to 3.6 | Raised |
| Manageable operating expenses (US$B) | 20.2 | 24.2 to 25.5 | n/a | n/a | Raised |
Implied fourth-quarter ramp. The production range is wide because it absorbs the Búzios profit-oil step-down and scheduled maintenance; the midpoint implies about 2.89 MMbpd of oil against 2.832 in the third quarter. The spending lines are not wide. Cash capex of $6.5-7.5B in one quarter compares with $5.4B in the third and includes the auction bonuses. Implied fourth-quarter operating cash flow of $12.3-17.3B compares with $12.0B in the third, and the top of that range needs both the 140 Mbpd timing recovery and a Brent that held near October levels, which it has not.
Street at: third-quarter revenue consensus sat between $31.3B and $33.1B and recurring EPS consensus at $1.23, with a higher set at $1.38. The post-print debate on the Street is about the November 23 plan rather than the fourth quarter: whether the 2026 overshoot is pulled-forward spending that 2027 gives back, or a new run rate.
Guidance style. Changed. In May and August management declined to raise anything into a strong tape, which we credited. In November it raised all but one line at once, holding only refining capex, and the cost lines rose by more in percentage terms than the production lines. The production raise is conservative; the cost raises arrived ahead of the plan rather than inside it.
What the guidance still does not include. No Brent assumption for the revision, no 2027 figures, no gross debt target for year end, no figure for any Braskem contribution, and no estimate of fourth-quarter subsidy revenue at the new R$2.12 rate.
Analyst Q&A Highlights
Whether the Company Is Inside Its Own Price Policy
The dominant line of questioning on the call was whether domestic prices sit inside the bands the policy defines and, if not, what the board would do. The answers confirmed that the policy is measured over the year, that the year is not over, and that an undisclosed internal discussion is under way; they did not say whether the company is inside the band today.
Q: "Now, I would like to go back to fuel prices in a more objective way. On average for the year, can you confirm whether the company is meeting the established price range? If you are falling outside of that range, what would be the process within the board to ultimately propose an extension to be able to move the price back to that established range?"
— Multiple analysts incl. Bruno Montanari (Morgan Stanley), Gabriel Barra (Citi), Regis Cardoso (XP), Tasso Vasconcellos (UBS)
A: "Today, it cannot be stated that we are falling short of our price policy. After all, the year has not ended yet, and we continue to pursue the same price policy. ... As I said before, given the geopolitical scenario and given that this war is not coming to an end in the near-term, we are analyzing how we can live with that issue, but this is still under discussion. There is no forecast of a structural change to our current price policy."
— Angélica Laureano, Executive Officer for Logistics, Commercialization and Market
Assessment: A policy measured over a calendar year that ends in seven weeks, with an internal review under way and the war described as not ending soon, is a policy whose adherence will be decided after the fact. Five separate questions converged on the point and none received a yes or no.
A Published Pricing Account, the Subsidy, and an Extended Deadline
The last pricing question proposed a published quarterly account of price gaps, as another Latin American state oil company uses. The answer declined it and, in doing so, gave the most informative pricing disclosure of the call: the subsidy is part of how prices are held down, diesel should meet the policy by year end, gasoline may not, and the measurement deadline may be extended.
Q: "If you'll allow me, I'd like to take the opportunity to use this forum to go back to your price policy again, because I think the market, Ecopetrol, a state-run oil company from Colombia, they have the numbers which are published to the market every quarter, and this is widely accepted, and it generates an accommodation for risks, so to speak, that's very interesting."
— Vicente Falanga, Bradesco BBI
A: "I think we failed to mention that the subsidies we've received from the federal government have also helped to accommodate those prices for the market in general. What we're now looking into is, we believe that by the end of this fiscal year, we will be able to meet our policy, at least, when it comes to diesel. There are still questions about gasoline prices, but those questions come from the fact that there's no confirmation of whether the policy will account for the year through December 2026. We might extend the deadline to be able to meet the policy-established limits, and we're looking into that."
— Angélica Laureano, Executive Officer for Logistics, Commercialization and Market
Assessment: The admission that the subsidies help "accommodate those prices" closes the loop we described in August: the treasury pays so that Petrobras can hold prices down, and Petrobras books the payment as revenue. The gasoline subsidy has already lapsed, so extending the deadline is the remaining tool for that product. Nothing in the answer suggests a price increase.
Whether This Year's Capex Overshoot Comes Out of Next Year's
The capex question that mattered most was whether the 2026 overshoot is spending pulled forward from 2027. Engineering's answer was that the pace continues, and finance deferred the number to the plan.
Q: "The company has been able to deliver a higher CapEx than it had planned for initially this year. I just wanted to understand for next year if there is any room for flexibility or for investments planned for future years could be moved forward to 2027, or maybe projects in your portfolio could be moved forward, seeing as you have capacity to deliver. I just wanted to understand whether that investment that we saw this year entails a lower CapEx next year."
— Bruno Amorim, Goldman Sachs
A: "Next year, we plan to keep up the same pace. We are already doing that with regards to several projects, many of which had already been secured."
— Renata Baruzzi, Executive Officer for Engineering, Technology and Innovation
A: "Our strategic plan for 2031 will be delivered on November 23rd, and that should give you an updated overview of all the investments we plan to have in our next cycle."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
Assessment: This is the exchange that moved us. If 2026 had been an acceleration that 2027 gives back, the revision would be a timing matter. "Keep up the same pace" means $21-22B of cash capex is the new base, two weeks before a plan for a five-year cycle is published by a re-elected government.
What the Capex Increase Is Made Of
A follow-up asked for the decomposition. The answer split it into exchange rates, platform construction progress, local-content nationalisation and subsea tie-ins, and stressed that none of it is cost overrun.
Q: "You mentioned a significant foreign exchange impact and a better execution performance. So if you could maybe add some color as to the real exchange impact and how much of the CapEx because of your operations in Búzios, TEP, or in CPR, and also the impact of nationalization in Búzios 9 and 10."
— Leonardo Marcondes, Bank of America
A: "Let me start with the foreign exchange impact, which is by over $1 billion to normalize our overall CapEx."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
A: "As I'd mentioned earlier, 40% of our CapEx increase derived from the better performance and construction of new platforms. ... As for nationalization, we've had about $600 million in nationalizing them. In addition to that, we've had an increased number of underwater interconnections with about $500 million being invested in that."
— Renata Baruzzi, Executive Officer for Engineering, Technology and Innovation
Assessment: The decomposition is credible and the absence of overruns is a genuine improvement on this company's history. It also shows that most of the increase is choice rather than cost: faster construction, more wells, more tie-ins. A choice made because Brent was high is the behaviour the capital-discipline pillar exists to track.
The Fourth-Quarter Lease Step-Up
Two questions pressed on the lease guidance, which implies a fourth quarter well above the third. The answers attributed most of it to support and transport vessels and said the company expects to land at the low end.
Q: "I just wanted to understand a little bit better how you are looking at, first of all, the need for additional drills next year, or additional rigs next year, and support vessels, as well as your availability for chartering."
— Multiple analysts incl. Rodrigo Almeida (BTG Pactual), Monique Greco Natal (Itaú BBA)
A: "Yeah, just adding to the numbers, about 75% of the increase come from the hiring of the OSVs and the maintenance of about 15 transportation vessels for oil, as well as a lower percentage coming from the addition of FPSO Tartaruga Verde. We changed the guidance because we understand we should be at the lower band of that range for the sake of forecasts."
— Fernando Melgarejo, Chief Financial and Investor Relations Officer
Assessment: Leases are the cost line that sits outside the capex headline and outside free cash flow as the policy defines it, yet they are paid in cash. Guiding to the low end of a raised range is a modest reassurance. The fleet additions are tied to production, but they are also multi-year commitments made at peak freight rates.
Braskem: Integration, a Deadline, and No Answer on Money
A question on petrochemical integration ended on the point that matters for the equity: what guarantees Petrobras would need before putting money into the affiliate. The answer took up only the integration half. It described integration with petrochemicals as strategy, said the company "will be in Braskem" and gave a deadline for the restructuring, but it did not address guarantees and gave no amount.
Q: "As an excellent oil and gas producer, how important is it to you for Petrobras to have verticalized integration in your petrochemical business in Mexico and outside of Latin America? ... What type of guarantees would you like to have from Braskem to feel comfortable putting your money in the company?"
— Lilyanna Yang, HSBC
A: "With regards to Braskem, the answer is yes. Not only Braskem, but we are also looking into other alternatives because we have a lot of ethane in the Rota 3 of our UPGNs in Boaventura, our natural gas plants. ... We will be in Braskem. ... and we are interested in closing an RE with Braskem. We are working towards that. We have until the 22nd to close ranks on that issue."
— William França, Executive Officer for Industrial Processes and Products
Assessment: In May the answer on the same subject was a boundary. In November it is "We will be in Braskem," a statement of intent to take part in the restructuring, and a date. The question of guarantees went unanswered. The $1.4B joint proposal reported the same day fits that answer. Management did not say what share of it is Petrobras'. That share sets the size of the exposure, but our August signpost fires on a signed commitment of any size.
How Búzios Declines, and What 2027 Adds
A question on 2027 asked how the new systems combine with decline in the largest field. The answer clarified that Búzios is not declining at all, because it has not peaked, and deferred 2027 to the plan.
Q: "Now, when we look at 2027, and I will not mention the curve for the entire year, but specifically for the rest of the year. There are three systems that you plan to add. ... So if possible, I'd like you to discuss how the decline in the Búzios field has performed versus what you initially expected, and how these new systems combined with this decline rate could bring in terms of potential for next year."
— Milene Carvalho, JPMorgan
A: "Just to clarify, with regards to the decline, we only count it as decline when we reach the top. So Búzios is a field that's still going up, so there's no decline yet. Its production is still growing."
— Sylvia Anjos, Chief Exploration and Production Officer
Assessment: The clarification is useful and positive: the field carrying the growth plan has not started to decline, and the group-level decline rate the CEO cites has fallen to about 3% a year from about 10%. The production pillar is the strongest part of the case and this exchange reinforced it.
What They're NOT Saying
- The export tax, for the second quarter running. The $867M charge and its extension to December 31 are disclosed in note 13.4 of the interim statements and in the one-off table. The tax was not mentioned in the prepared remarks or the Q&A.
- The distribution amount. R$15.3B, 18.2% lower than August in dollars and paid in 2027, was in the Material Fact and the interim statements. The amount was not cited on the call; the only references to dividends were generic.
- The election. The runoff was two weeks earlier and moved the ADR 14.0% in a session. The word does not appear in the transcript; the CEO referred instead to questions about leadership turnover and "the internal instability of Brazil."
- The size of any Braskem contribution. The industrial director said "We will be in Braskem" and gave a deadline, but did not address guarantees or an amount. The interim statements describe only the June shareholders' agreement and do not mention the extrajudicial recovery, the proposed contribution or Petrobras' share of it.
- When the subsidy receivable converts to cash. The balance is disclosed in note 28.1.1 ($3,168M), with a $538M October receipt and the remainder "awaiting documentation analysis by ANP." What is absent is a timetable, an end date for the R$2.12 diesel rate, and its cost.
- How far gasoline sits from the policy band. Management conceded gasoline may not meet the policy this year and that the deadline may be extended, but gave no size for the gap.
- A 2027 capex number. "The same pace" was the only guidance; the number was deferred to November 23.
- A gross debt target. The CFO framed the plan in net debt terms. No year-end gross figure was given, and the $67B gross target for 2026 stated in May has not been restated since.
- The cash breakeven. The $59 Brent figure from May has not been updated, in the quarter when opex, capex and lease guidance all rose. The transcript's only use of the term was to say the pricing policy has no Brent break-even.
Market Reaction
- Pre-print setup: the ADR closed at $18.28 on November 10, before the results were furnished after the close. It entered the print up 54.3% year to date from $11.85 at the end of 2025 and up 40.5% over the trailing twelve months, but down 27.7% over the trailing thirty days from $25.30, against a 52-week closing range of $11.54 to $26.16. The S&P 500 was up 9.9% year to date.
- The thirty days before the print: the ADR rose 11.5% to $24.14 on October 5 after the first round of the presidential election, closed at a 52-week high of $26.16 on October 23, and fell 14.0% to $22.50 on October 26 after the runoff, on 102.6 million shares. The Brazil country ETF fell 19.8% the same session. Brent fell 21.6% from $116.72 on October 23 to $91.49 on November 10.
- Reaction session: PBR opened at $17.60 on November 11, a gap down of 3.7%, recovered to $17.82 within the first five minutes, and reached a session high of $18.17 shortly before the 11:00 AM call. It held near that morning high during the call, faded through the afternoon and closed at $17.82, down 2.5% or $0.46. The S&P 500 rose 1.3%.
- Volume: 24.9 million shares against a 28.0 million thirty-day average, 0.9 times, though that average is inflated by the election sessions.
- Local lines: on B3 the common shares fell 2.09% and the preferred 3.11%; the preferred ADR fell 3.1%. The decline was not a currency effect.
A 17.5% recurring earnings beat, a revenue beat against two of three estimate sets, a production guide raised by 200,000 barrels a day and an operating cash flow guide raised by up to $15B produced a 2.5% decline on a day the S&P 500 rose 1.3%. The intraday path shows why. The stock opened on the overnight release, spent the morning recovering to within 0.6% of the prior close as the operating detail was absorbed, and gave it back after a call in which the capex and pricing questions received no reassuring answer. The preferred ADR fell further than the common.
The longer view is starker. The ADR is 0.8% below where it closed after the August print, while Brent is 11.0% higher than on that day, at $92.76 against $83.55. Between August and November the equity gave up its sensitivity to the oil price: the rally into October was an election trade, the October 26 session reversed it, and the November print added a capital budget that rises with Brent and a distribution that did not. The market has started to price Petrobras as a fiscal instrument with an oil field attached.
Street Perspective
Debate: Is the Capex Reset Value-Creating Acceleration or the Windfall Absorbed?
Bull view: the bull case is that bringing barrels forward in a $90 tape is exactly what an owner should want. Projects are on budget, eleven platforms run above design, the production guide rose by 200,000 barrels a day, and cash spent now on Búzios earns more than cash returned.
Bear view: the bear camp argues that the CFO described the mechanism himself: higher Brent produced more cash and more cash produced more capex, and 2027 runs at the same pace. Opex, capex and leases rose together by $9B to $12B against original guidance, and the plan due November 23 is being written by a re-elected government at the top of the cycle.
Our take: the bears. The acceleration is real and well executed, and it still transfers the windfall from the distribution to the budget by design. What makes it a downgrade is not this year's spend but engineering's answer that next year will "keep up the same pace," with the numbers deferred to the November 23 plan.
Debate: Does 45% of Free Cash Flow Still Mean a Rising Distribution?
Bull view: some desks argue that the policy held: 45% was applied, coverage was 1.42 times, and nine-month declarations annualise to a gross yield above 9% at the current price.
Bear view: the skeptics note that the distribution fell 18% in dollars in a quarter with Brent at $97, that offshore holders lose 10% to 17.5% to withholding, and that the base of the formula is free cash flow after a capex line management has just raised by roughly a quarter.
Our take: the bears again. The formula is intact; its input is not. With Brent back toward the plan's assumption and capex at the new base, the distribution per ADS falls to roughly $1.07-1.21 a year on our arithmetic, against $1.66 annualised this year.
Debate: Is the Subsidy and Price-Policy Architecture a Hedge or a Dependency?
Bull view: a growing consensus view is that the subsidy protected both margin and market share through an extraordinary price shock, that refining earned 19% EBITDA margins as a result, and that diesel will be inside the policy by year end.
Bear view: the other side observes that 9.2% of revenue now comes from the treasury, that the receivable rose 56.8% to $3.2B, that the diesel rate nearly doubled with no end date, that the gasoline subsidy lapsed while gasoline remains below the band, and that the policy's deadline may be extended.
Our take: a dependency. A hedge has an exit. This mechanism grows when the oil price rises and has no disclosed path to removal other than a domestic price increase that management spent the call declining to commit to.
Debate: At Three Times EBITDA, Is All of This Already in the Price?
Bull view: the bull case is that the ADR has fallen 27.7% in thirty days and trades at about 3.0 times enterprise value to trailing adjusted EBITDA and 3.5 times annualised nine-month recurring earnings, with net debt at 1.0 times EBITDA and a standalone credit upgrade in hand.
Bear view: the bears reply that the multiple sits on war-level Brent and war-level subsidies. On August's measures the ADR traded at 3.3 times and 3.7 times; it is cheaper by about a tenth on EBITDA that the company's own planning case does not expect to persist.
Our take: the price assumes that the war-level Brent persists. On the plan's Brent and the new capex base the distribution supports roughly $13-17 per ADS; only if the guidance-year cash flows repeat in 2027 does the current price sit near the bottom of value. We would rather wait for the plan.
Model Update & Valuation Framework
| Item | Prior parameter (2Q26) | Revised | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oil production, Brazil (FY26) | 2.62 to 2.68 MMbpd | 2.70 to 2.75 MMbpd | 9M26 at 2.702; Búzios profit-oil step-down of about 85 kbpd and maintenance in 4Q26 |
| Total own production (FY26) | 3.30 to 3.36 MMboed | 3.33 to 3.38 MMboed | 9M26 at 3.359; company range 3.3 to 3.4 |
| Refining utilization (FY26) | 97% to 99% | 98% to 99% | 9M26 at 99% |
| Oil products output (FY26) | 1.87 to 1.92 MMbpd | 1.86 to 1.88 MMbpd | 9M26 at 1.869; RPBC turnaround in 3Q26 |
| DD&A (FY26) | $16.8B to $17.2B | $17.2B to $17.4B | 9M26 at $12,856M; 3Q26 at $4,482M |
| Total capex, company definition (FY26) | $20.5B to $22.0B | $24.0B to $25.5B | Company guidance; 9M26 at $16,829M |
| Cash capex (FY26) | $18.0B to $19.0B | $21.0B to $22.0B | Company guidance; 9M26 at $14,474M; includes about $0.6B of auction bonuses |
| Cash capex (FY27) | not modelled | $21.0B to $22.0B | "Next year, we plan to keep up the same pace"; to be revised on the November 23 plan |
| Manageable operating expenses (FY26) | $23.5B to $24.5B | $24.2B to $25.5B | Company guidance |
| Lease payments (FY26) | $10.0B plan | $11.0B to $11.2B | Company range $11.0B to $11.5B; management expects the lower end |
| Gross debt (year-end 2026) | $68B to $70B | $69B to $71B | $69,970M at September 30; 4Q26 lease additions |
| Effective tax rate (FY26) | 29% to 31% | 29% to 30% | 9M26 at 29.0% |
| Fuel subsidy revenue | $1.5B to $2.0B per quarter | At least $3.0B in 4Q26 | $3,044M in 3Q26, earned mostly at R$1.12 a litre; the diesel rate is R$2.12 from September 27 |
| Crude export tax | $0.8B to $1.0B per quarter | $0.8B to $1.0B in 4Q26; nil from 2027 unless renewed | $867M in 3Q26 at 12% (6% to the EU); in force to December 31, 2026 |
| Distribution policy | 45% of free cash flow, ordinary only | Unchanged formula; FY26 declarations $10B to $13B | 9M26 at $8,037M; 4Q26 depends on implied FCF of roughly $5B to $11B |
Valuation framework. At $17.82 per ADS across 6,444 million ADS-equivalent shares, the equity is capitalised near $115B on a common-share-equivalent basis. Adding $57.8B of net debt gives an enterprise value near $173B. The disclosed 1.00 times net-debt-to-LTM-adjusted-EBITDA ratio implies trailing adjusted EBITDA near $57.8B, so the ADR trades at roughly 3.0 times, against 3.3 times at the August print. Nine-month recurring net income of $24,924M annualises to $33.2B, or 3.5 times, against 3.7 times on annualised first-half earnings in August. Nine-month declarations of $8,037M, about $1.25 per ADS, annualise to $1.66, a gross yield of about 9.3%.
We value the equity on the distribution it can sustain, because the policy ties what holders receive to free cash flow after capex. Two cases bound it.
- Plan Brent. The 2026 plan assumed operating cash flow of $35B at a Brent near $60 to $63. Scaled for the production guide, 3.3 to 3.4 MMboed against 3.1, that is roughly $37B to $38B. Less cash capex at the new $21-22B base, free cash flow is about $15B to $17B, 45% of which is $6.9B to $7.8B, or $1.07 to $1.21 per ADS. At a 7% to 8% gross yield that supports $13 to $17.
- Guidance Brent persists. Operating cash flow of $45B to $50B less the same capex gives free cash flow of $23B to $29B, distributions of $10.4B to $13.1B, and $1.61 to $2.03 per ADS. At today's 9.3% yield that supports $17 to $22.
Valuation impact. Our fair-value range falls to $14 to $17 per ADS from $18 to $22, weighted toward the plan-Brent case for three reasons: management's own planning view since August has been for Brent to move back toward plan assumptions, Brent has already fallen 21.6% from its October high, and the capex base that sets the distribution has been raised for 2026 and, on engineering's word, held for 2027. The August range assumed a capex line inside a $16.9B band; that band no longer exists. The stock at $17.82 sits above the top of our range and at the bottom of the case that requires the war-level cash flows to repeat. That is an Underperform: the shares do not need the oil price to fall to disappoint, only to stop rising while the budget keeps growing.
August Commitments, Graded
| Commitment to watch (August checklist) | Outcome | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Subsidy receivables: a disclosed balance and evidence of collection | Balance disclosed at $3,168M, up from $2,021M; $538M received in October; remainder awaiting ANP documentation review | Not met |
| 2. Export tax: rate, legal basis, duration, classification | 12% on crude (6% to the EU) under Camex resolutions until December 31, 2026; diesel leg ended; still a one-off | Extended |
| 3. New strategic plan: whether the 2026-2030 envelope is lifted | Plan due November 23; 2026 cash capex already raised 24% to 30% | Pending |
| 4. Cash capex vs. $16.9B +/-5% | Revised to $21-22B | Broken |
| 5. Opex vs. $20.2B | Revised to $24.2-25.5B | Broken |
| 6. Gross debt and any interim target | $69,970M, down $836M; no gross target; plan framed in net debt | Partly |
| 7. Braskem after the October 24 injunction expiry | Extrajudicial recovery filed August 24; $1.4B joint contribution proposed; "We will be in Braskem" | Boundary not restated |
| 8. H2 diesel imports and the Cubatão turnaround | Diesel imports 110 Mbpd as flagged; RPBC turnaround done; utilisation 99% | Met |
| 9. China export share diversification | 40% against 35% in 2Q26 and 62% in 1Q26 | Mostly held |
Thesis Scorecard Post-Earnings
The pillars below are the standing thesis established in May and carried through August, graded against this quarter's print and call. They are not re-derived.
| Thesis Point | Status | Status tag | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bull #1: Pre-salt production compounds through 2030 on project delivery | Confirmed | ON TRACK (unchanged) | Record 3,512 Mboed, up 11.7% YoY; pre-salt oil up 15.9%; guidance raised to 2.7-2.8 MMbpd oil; eleven platforms above design capacity; Búzios not yet declining. Offset: about 85 kbpd of Búzios profit oil passes to the state from 4Q26. |
| Bull #2: Refining self-sufficiency converts crude spikes into margin | Confirmed | ON TRACK (unchanged) | Segment EBITDA up 65.1% to $5,880M at a 19% margin; record 769 Mbpd diesel output; ROCE 15.5%. The margin includes $3,044M of subsidy and $867M of export tax; diesel imports returned to 110 Mbpd seasonally. |
| Bull #3: Falling cash breakeven de-risks the downside case | Challenged | ON TRACK to AT RISK | Lifting cost fell to $6.12/boe, the lowest since 3Q24, but 2026 opex guidance rose 20% to 26%, cash capex 24% to 30% and leases 10% to 15%. The breakeven that matters to holders, including capex and leases, rose; the $59 figure was not updated. |
| Bull #4: The 45%-of-free-cash-flow policy delivers a rising distribution | Challenged | ON TRACK to AT RISK | The formula was applied and covered 1.42 times, but the declaration fell 18.2% in dollars and 11.9% in reais, and its base is free cash flow after a capex line that management raised and will hold in 2027. |
| Bear #1: The state sets the domestic price and now taxes the exports | Confirmed | MATERIALIZING (unchanged, escalated) | Subsidy at 9.2% of revenue and $3,168M receivable; diesel rate raised to R$2.12 a litre; export tax extended to December 31; pricing policy under "situational" review with a possible deadline extension for gasoline. |
| Bear #2: Capital discipline erodes as the oil price rises | Confirmed | MATERIALIZING (unchanged, escalated) | The CFO tied the capex increase to Brent directly; every headline cost line was raised; "Next year, we plan to keep up the same pace"; 21 new blocks, Africa entries and the Logum purchase added in the quarter. |
| Bear #3: Deleveraging is contingent rather than committed | Neutral | MATERIALIZING (unchanged, softened) | Gross debt fell $836M to $69,970M, missing the $69B signpost; net debt fell 4.2% to $57,847M on a cash build and leverage reached 1.00 times; the CFO re-anchored the plan target to net debt. |
| Bear #4: Earnings quality leans on items that do not repeat | Confirmed | EMERGING to MATERIALIZING | The recurring line consensus measures includes $3,044M of subsidy, about 21.6% of recurring net income after tax at the statutory rate, and excludes an $867M export tax that is legally in force. Adjusted both ways, recurring EPS is $1.05 against $1.23. |
Signposts Published in August, Graded
| Signpost (verbatim) | Type | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| "subsidy receivables collected and disclosed with a balance by the third quarter" | Upgrade | Not met: disclosed, not collected; balance up 56.8% |
| "the 2026 capital budget confirmed inside the guided band when the new strategic plan is published" | Upgrade | Not met: the band was raised to $21-22B before the plan |
| "gross debt below $69B at the third quarter" | Upgrade | Not met: $69,970M |
| "a new plan that lifts the 2026 to 2030 capex envelope by more than 10%" | Downgrade | Pending: plan due November 23; 2026 cash capex alone up 24% to 30% |
| "a Braskem capital commitment of any size" | Downgrade | Being pulled: $1.4B joint proposal, non-binding at publication |
| "the export tax being extended or raised" | Downgrade | Fired: extended to December 31, 2026 |
| "a negotiated de-escalation that returns Brent to the plan assumption before the subsidy receivables are collected" | Downgrade | Not fired: Brent $92.76 on November 11; no negotiated settlement |
The May note's downgrade signpost "a 2026 capex figure revised above $21B" was replaced in August with the five-year envelope test above. We note for the record that the 2026 figure has now been revised to $24-25.5B on the total definition and $21-22B on the cash definition.
Overall: thesis weakened. The operating pillars are as strong as at any point in our coverage, and refining has finally passed its financial test. But both cash-return pillars moved to at risk in the same quarter: the breakeven rose with every headline cost line, and the distribution's base is now the variable management chose to grow. On the bear side, all four points are confirmed or materialising, and the state's claim on the company grew through the subsidy rate, the export tax extension, the Búzios profit-oil step-down and a pricing review, while a re-elected government prepares the plan that will set the next five years.
Action: Underperform, downgraded from Hold. Of the three upgrade signposts we published in August, none was met. Of the four downgrade signposts, one fired outright, one is being negotiated and one awaits the plan. We said in August that a stock just below the bottom of an $18-22 range was a Hold with upgrade optionality; at $17.82 against a $14-17 range, it is a stock priced for the war-level cash flows to repeat. Signposts back to Hold, each outside our base case: 2027 cash capex in the November 23 plan below $19B; the subsidy receivable below $1.5B at year end; or gross debt below $67B at year end. Signposts that would raise our conviction in the downgrade: a signed Braskem contribution of any size; a 2027-2031 plan that lifts the capex envelope by more than 10%; an extension of the pricing policy's measurement window for gasoline; or the export tax renewed beyond December 31. If a plan below $19B arrives alongside a signed Braskem contribution, the two offset and the rating stays at Underperform.